What Are the Disadvantages of a Metal Roof?

What Are the Disadvantages of a Metal Roof?

If you own a home with an asphalt roof, you might be considering upgrading to a metal one. Researchers estimate that metal roofs are the second most popular roofing option in the United States. They are energy-efficient, durable, and environmentally friendly. Metal roofs do have drawbacks, though. The last thing you want is to spend tens of thousands of dollars, only to find that it doesn’t fit your needs. Here’s everything you need to know to answer, “What are the disadvantages of a metal roof?”

The Cost

At Brava Roof Tile, we recommend high-quality roofing to all home or business owners. Investing in long-lasting material often comes with what may seem like an exorbitant price tag, though. That’s especially true of metal roofs. According to Modernize, the average metal roof installation costs between $9,545 and $16,582. That translates to $5 to $14 per square foot. In comparison, conventional asphalt roofs are three to five times cheaper. Metal roofs come in different varieties, with copper being the most expensive and coveted. This material lasts upwards of 200 years and costs $14 to $22 per foot. Other metal roofing materials cost:

  • Aluminum: $3.25 to $5.75 per square foot
  • Corrugated metal: $1.80 to $2.50 per square foot
  • Standing seam metal: $4 to $12 per square foot
  • Steel: $3.35 to $4.50 per square foot
  • Tin: $3.25 to $14.65 per square foot
  • Zinc: $5.65 to $11 per square foot

Keep in mind that a more expensive roof can increase costs elsewhere. An insurance appraiser may boost your home’s estimated worth after an on-site inspection. If that happens, you would have to pay higher premiums on your insurance and more property taxes.

Harder to Find Qualified Installers

metal roof installer

Metal roofs are not as straightforward to install as other roofing materials. You may also find relatively few companies and contractors than specialize in metal roof installation. The confluence makes it challenging to find knowledgeable and experienced professionals to complete the job. While it's tempting to try a DIY installation, the risks outweigh the rewards. This particular job requires specialized tools, and if errors occur, they can result in extensive and expensive repairs. You also may pick the wrong type of material for your home or injure yourself during the installation.

Tendency to Dent

Dented Metal Roof

While metal roofs can dent, it’s not likely. You would need a massive hailstorm to strike your home. Regular hail wouldn't make a noticeable impact. However, larger pieces of frozen rain can leave visible dents in your roof. Dents may not compromise the structural integrity of your roof, but they can lead to a host of other problems. These blemishes can lower your property’s overall curb appeal. If you’re trying to sell your home, you’ll have a hard time doing so if visitors spot dings on your roof. If you do want to fix the dents, it is not cheap! According to Howmuch.net, the average metal roof repair costs $1200 per 100 square foot.

The Industrial Aesthetic

Metal roofs come with a love-hate look. If you want a chic, modern, and industrial aesthetic, then metal roofs may work for you. However, if you prefer a neutral or classic appearance, you need to choose a different roofing material, such as shake or slate. You may end up butting heads with your local Homeowners Association about your roof. Some HOAs have strict rules and regulations that limit what type of roofing material you can use. Some municipalities have even considered banning metal roofs outright. Metal roofs are also prone to “oil canning.” The effect creates visible waves on the flat sections of your roof. The phenomenon, also known as elastic buckling, occurs on steel, aluminum, and copper.

Metal Roofing Alternative

When people want high quality roofs that they can trust, they contact Brava Roof Tile. We manufacture state-of-the-art synthetic roofing systems including cedar shake shingles, slate, and barrel tiles that outperform metal roofs.

brava shake roof
brava barrel

For the ultimate alternative, choose Brava's synthetic roof tiles. Unlike metal roofs, Brava synthetic roofing materials are made out of recycled plastics and other sustainable materials, which make them a lightweight roofing alternative.

With a Brava roof, there is never a need to worry about chipping paint, dents, cracking or rusting! Brava Roof Tile is an extremely durable option that is available in Class 4 Impact Rating and Class A or C Fire Rating. Our roof tile is virtually maintenance free!

When considering the cons that come with metal roofs, it's easier to choose the alternative. If you're searching for a durable and lightweight roofing system that is better than a metal roof, choose Brava Roof Tile!

Get Inspired - Click Here to Order Your Complimentary Lookbook.