Metal Roof vs Shingles in Hot Climates

Metal Roof vs Shingles 1

Instead of staying outside during the summer months, many take solace indoors, where they can crank up the air conditioning and hide from the heat.

But not all roof materials are suited for hot climates, though two options people often consider are asphalt shingles and metal roofs.

Here’s everything you need to know to choose between a metal roof vs shingles in hot climates.

Hot Climates and Roofing Needs

Before you can debate the merits between a metal roof vs shingles in hot climate areas, you need to understand what a hot climate is and what to look for in roofing materials.

A hot climate is a region that experiences prolonged periods of high heat and other severe weather events, like thunderstorms.

When roofing materials are exposed to this climate, they can degrade quickly under the sun's intense heat. Therefore, hot climate roofing materials should be:

  • Durable: The roof should be able to withstand the sun's heat and UV rays with minimal damage and tropical storms.

  • Energy-Efficient: The material should have higher solar reflectance and thermal emittance properties.

  • A Light Color: Light colors better reflect the sun's heat, helping to keep homes cooler.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing refers to any roofing material made of metal, which can come in various colors of panels, sheets, and tiles. Most metal roofs are made out of steel or aluminum, though some other options include copper and galvanized steel.

Initially, metal roofs were for farms and industrial buildings, but homeowners began opting for metal roofs after discovering their benefits.

Benefits of Metal Roofing In Hot Climates

There are several benefits of using metal roofs in hot climates. To name a few:

Energy Efficiency

Metal is an energy-efficient material that reflects heat and keeps your home cooler, which also means you can save money on your utility bills.


It is also a fairly durable material that can withstand wind, rain, and extreme temperatures, though hail and debris can leave dent marks. Installed correctly, you'll have a roof for 50 years or more, with little maintenance required, as metal does not rot, warp, or have a risk of pest infestations.


Metal is also environmentally friendly and often made from recycled materials. This means that, at the end of its lifespan, you can recycle it again.

Negatives of Metal Roofing

Although there are some benefits to using a metal roofing, there a few disadvantages to consider:


On the downside, metal roofing isn't cheap and can cost more than asphalt shingles. The complex installation requirements of metal add to the cost, as you need an experienced professional to perform the task. Metal is also noisy; while some enjoy the sound of rain, others find it a nuisance.


While metal roofs reflect heat and prevent it from reaching the building below, that doesn't mean they don't get hot. Unpainted metal roofs can reach up to 145ºF, but special heat-reflective paints can add to their reflectivity, making them feel around 42% cooler.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are a common roofing material and are extremely popular throughout the United States. They are composed of multiple layers, including a base of either cellulose organic fibers or fiberglass, an asphalt coating, and a layer of ceramic or stone granules, and they come in various colors and styles.

Benefits of using Asphalt Shingles

The popularity of asphalt shingles is largely in part to two main benefits they hold. For example:


Their popularity is, in part, largely due to their affordability; it is a budget-friendly option that is easy to install.

Color Options

Most of the time, asphalt shingles have a lot of flexibility in terms of their design, coming in a variety of shades of color options.


Unlike metal shingles, asphalt shingles have a much more limited lifespan, lasting anywhere from 20 to 30 years, though it could be less depending on the climate.

The Negatives of Asphalt Shingles

Though there are a variety of benefits that come with asphalt shingles, there are two negatives to consider especially for hot climate areas:


Asphalt shingles are not as durable against weather, especially during tropical storms. AS a result, homes and buildings with asphalt shingles tend to need roof repairs much more often than those with more durable materials.


Because of their composition, asphalt roofs also tend to absorb and retain heat. This then causes them to not only increase the external temperature of the house but also the indoor temperature. The end result: high energy bills.

A Different Option To Build Your Roof With

While metal roofs come out on top in the debate of a metal roof vs shingles in a hot climate, that doesn't mean you should jump and get a metal roof. There is another option to consider, one that’s even better: Brava composite roof tiles.

Here are the benefits:


Brava offers roofing products in three authentic varieties: cedar shakes, slate tiles, and Spanish barrel tiles. Their patented multi-coloring process allows each tile to have a unique blend of colors that won't fade or bleach—while also giving each home a unique taste of style.

Extensive Durability

Brava surpasses both metal roofs and asphalt shingles in terms of durability.

All their products have Class A and Class C fire ratings and Class 4 impact ratings. Not to mention, they can withstand winds up to 211 MPH when installed with screws, making them the perfect solution to combat tropical storms.

Cool Roofing Capabilities

Brava’s products can also withstand heat and thermal cycles without getting damaged or getting too hot. In fact, Brava's cedar shakes and barrel tiles offer "cool roof" color options, which reflect more light and heat so that they can be used in hot climate areas.


Brava's composite roof tiles are a sustainable product made from plastics that would normally end up in a landfill. Similar to metal roofing, at the end of a composite roof's long lifespan, they can be recycled again.

Build A Roof to Keep Cool with Brava Roof Tiles

Living in a hot climate means air conditioning is something you can't live without. Fortunately, you don’t only have to choose between a metal roof vs asphalt shingles in hot climate areas.

The best thing to do is find a more suitable material for hot climates—one like Brava roof tiles.

To learn more about our composite roofing tiles and how they can help keep your home cool and lower your energy bill, contact Brava today!